18/02/2020 Communication Science news and articles

Quality of public debate and social media

Does social media add or subtract from the quality of public debate today? Aakansha shares her take on the controversial topic.

Social media in the 21st century, is the ubiquitous influence that parents want their children to stay away from. If it were a reliable source of knowledge acquisition, then one might consider news, scholarly articles, journals and books to be not only to be less appealing but potentially worthless. However, you can never be 100% confident whether or not the information you are exposed to on social networking sites is of good quality; let alone improving your existing knowledge.

What social media is not

Social media is a platform to showcase thoughts, opinions, personal pictures and these, may or may not be unrelated to offering substantial information improving the quality of public debate. I believe that at some point in the cycle of creating, sharing and ‘viralising’ content, genuine information, such as the news, becomes even harder to distinguish from fake news. And thus social media, in my opinion, does not improve the quality of public debate.

Social media can divide us

In the article, “Mass Media Flow and Differential Growth in Knowledge, it is clearly explained how and why the integration of social media can only benefit those who are well educated and have a higher socioeconomic status. This helps us infer that when the same exposure of social media is provided to one who is less educated; it only works as a misguidance and a distraction. This subsequent effect further increases the knowledge gap amongst the public; fostering a growing belief in disastrous phenomenon, such as, “fake news” and conspiracy theories. That being said, misleading information on social media can lower the quality of public debate by questioning the validity of established facts causing discord. 

Social media can silence us

In addition to the problem created above, one must acknowledge that social media is filled with strong ‘influencers’ whose opinions carry some power, affecting their long list of followers. Some social media influencers do not hesitate to twist the facts and figures, to satisfy their own personal or professional goals. This results in the encouragement of the ‘Spiral of Silence , a concept wherein people feel the constant need to suppress their opinions because they think they are in minority. The aforementioned, only creates more blind followers who spread half knowledge with conviction, not people who improved their quality of public debate.

Social media is the first not the final step towards improving the quality of public debate

One might argue that social media provides free, speedy access to knowledge for those who cannot afford it. It can be said that it increases their learning via multiple delivery channels, in the end, helping them contribute to a quality debate. However, it cannot be ignored that anything substantial that we find on social media should be able to be traced back to a valid as well as reliable source which, in fact, should be the ultimate source if the quality of information is to be kept in mind. Any other information that one receives must be proofed for error, in order for it to improve the quality of public debate.

Considering the good with the bad

We know that social media is a vast open platform that enables the masses to share and receive information. Therefore, as much as it can increase the chance of receiving quality information, it has equal probability of preaching illogical and inconsistent information. Thus to sum up we can say that social media can be a wonderful source to invoke the motivation to attain knowledge but it is not the one contributing to the improvement of public debate.    

Cover: Pixabay: kreatikar Final Editor: Erica Boyce



in Opinion
Related Posts

Medium Podcast #8 – Jade’s Pact

14/02/2020 and


The month in which Jade stopped using smartphones and developed a texting twitch (Parents Beware).

Personal Ads: Who needs Cupid?



From personal ads to dating apps, people have advertised themselves to find the best suitor. Medium tells you why cupid is out of business.

Parasite wins Best Picture without an ’English-speaking’ host



Parasite makes history at the 92nd Academy Awards by being the first non-English speaking film to win Best Picture, defeating eight other competing English-language movies. Danny tells us why Parasite deserved to win.

A day in the life of the FSR FMG’s official secretary



Have you ever wondered what the secretary of the FSR FMG does? Meet Robin while she tells about her job! The job that currency has a vacancy, so check it out!

“Trust the child within you”: Interview with Francis Alÿs

Medium interviewed Francis Alÿs, director of "Sandlines", which premiered in Europe at the International Film Festival in Rotterdam. His work is currently being exhibited at the Eye Film Museum in Amsterdam.

Black tie: A guide on formal attire



Your next formal event is coming up and no idea what to wear? Then this article is the perfect guide in what to wear in ‘black tie’ to the next formal event.  

The Lessons of a Mercurius Sales Committee Member



Have you ever wondered what the Sales Committee of the study association Mercurius exactly does? Margarete gives you an insight into the useful skills she has developed as part of the committee.

Vienna: City of dreams



The Austrian capital is a worldwide famous destination with all sorts of architecture, museums, and landmarks to visit. If you are an art or history lover, a foodie, or you just get a thrill out of traveling to a new place; Vienna is the place for you!

AMFI-film screening 2020: Student works of art about fashion and identity

09/02/2020 and


Medium had the opportunity to attend the 2020 Fashion Film Screening & Photo-exhibition created by AMFI students. This was our take.

‘Taylor Swift: Miss Americana’: How The Pop Supernova Found Her Voice



Emma analyses 'Miss Americana,' the documentary about Taylor Swift. In this, Swift narrates her life as a pop star and a woman in her 20's.

Vegan for a month: a new veganning or a big missed-steak?



Dry-January not quite your thing? Maybe give veganism a go. Gabby explores veganism for herself, and leaves us with some tasty tips!

Afgeserveerd voedsel wordt steeds meer uitgeserveerd



Steeds meer initiatieven richten zich op het tegengaan van voedselverspilling. En dat is maar goed ook, want jaarlijks verdwijnt een derde van al het voedsel in de vuilnisbak.

Hoe ik een maand mijn smartphone opgaf



Geen smartphone voor een maand: hoe kan dat tegenwoordig? Jade ging deze uitdaging aan en vertelt waarom iedereen het een keertje moet proberen.

FSR 101: A crash course on what the student council does for your student rights

03/02/2020 and


Medium breaks down the influence that the Faculty Student Council of UvA's Faculty of Social and Behavioral Sciences has on our community and how you can participate to make a change.

Duolingo: The Boogieman of Language Apps



The green owl goes rogue - this article discusses Duolingo's (almost extreme) methods to coerce us into practicing our language skills.

mersin escort mersin escort mersin escort canlı tv konya escort