fbpx
06/08/2020 The Communication Science magazine

Is Hamilton Getting #Cancelled?

In this article, Rita writes about the in-demand musical Hamilton and the criticism it receives.


Hamilton, the critically acclaimed musical which found its way to the hearts of musical lovers, and others, since 2015 has now found a new life on Disney plus+. With its new audience reach, the musical is now facing more criticism, with many accusing the show to downplay the connections between the historic figures and slavery. Is Hamilton getting #cancelled?

Hamilton: An American Musical 101

In 2009, Lin-Manuel Miranda, accompanied by Alex Lacamoire, performed at the White House Evening of Poetry, Music, and the Spoken Word. He introduced his performance by stating that it was a part of a hip hop concept album he was working on, which was about a man he believed to embody the essence of hip hop: Treasury secretary Alexander Hamilton. This was met with laughter but the performance proved to be remarkable and ended with a standing ovation.

By February 2015, the concept album had developed into a fully-fledged musical, which premiered at the Public Theatre. Hamilton: An American Musical, inspired by a biography by Ron Chernow, tells the tale of the 10-dollar founding father, Alexander Hamilton, from his departure to New York to the duel that would ultimately end his life in 1804. With its diverse cast, hip hop influenced tracks, and even rap battles between founding fathers, Hamilton quickly became a phenomenon and premiered on Broadway in August of the same year. 

The Criticism

On July 3rd, a recorded 2016 performance of the show with its original Broadway cast was released on Disney+. While met with enthusiasm by numerous fans around the world, it exposed the musical to further criticism, and as per usual with internet culture, a “#cancel”. The main issue that has been raised is the portrayal of the relationship of the historic characters with slavery, especially Hamilton.

Amongst the musical’s themes of loss, forgiveness, conflict, and legacy, the topic of slavery is not primary on the list. Nonetheless, despite not being the central theme of the musical, slavery is mentioned throughout the show, although often through John Laurens, who in the musical claims “we’ll never be free until we end slavery”. Hamilton, as the character, does speak negatively of slavery, in instants where he reminds Thomas Jefferson that Virginia’s debts are only paid “’cause [they] don’t pay for labor. Passages like those however tend to be brief and relatively scarce. 

The impression one can get from the musical alone is that Alexander Hamilton was an abolitionist. This has been highlighted as an issue, with many mentioning his connection with the slave-owning Schuyler family, or his close relationship with slave-owning Founding fathers, such as George Washington

The truth is that Hamilton’s stance towards slavery is complicated. Although Hamilton has been praised and declared to have been a strong public abolitionist by some biographers, he has also been described as having anti-slavery views but being able to compromise on those and look the other way when convenient. Miranda himself has recognized in an interview that despite voicing anti-slavery beliefs, Hamilton “remained complicit in the system”.

So, where does this leave the musical?

#Cancelled?

At the end of the day, there is only so much exploration of complex decades of history that can be done in 2 hours and 40minutes. 

All criticism, as acknowledged by the musical’s creator, is valid. The issue of the portrayal of the reality of slavery, as well as the participation of the founding fathers in it, is an issue that has, can and should generate a debate. After all, the new string of critics mirrors the state of the world we currently live in, and no criticism on the portrayal of slavery would not only be odd but also alarming. As Miranda states

“You don’t get to control how you’re remembered […] the show doesn’t escape that fate […] different things in it will rise or fall based on where we are”.

Hamilton: An American Musical, is an art based on history. It has its strengths and it has its flaws. It should be praised for where it succeeds and held accountable for where it falls.

Cover: Disney +

Reacties

reacties

Related Posts

Teenage Girls in the Army: A Closer Look at the Fictional Country of Ravka

04/08/2020

04/08/2020

Fictional young girls and boys are fighting together in the army for their country Ravka. Danny explains why literature sets an example for equality in the military.

Folklore: Taylor Swift At Her Best While The World Is At Its Worst

01/08/2020

01/08/2020

Emma uses her Swiftie superpowers to unveil what’s hidden behind Taylor Swift's new album "folklore"

How Internet COVID-19 Face Mask Memes Tackle Skeptics in the Digital Age

30/07/2020

30/07/2020

In this article, Quynh talks about COVID-19 face mask memes. Are they just entertainment or do they also raise awareness?

The Secret Way to Good Grades – But One That Everyone Uses

29/07/2020

29/07/2020

Ritalin seems like the secret way to get a good grade when there is not enough time and too much workload. Jorrit explains why especially Communication Science students are keen to try it.

Delayed

24/07/2020

24/07/2020

In this article, Margarete dives into why Hollywood movie studios delayed the release dates of blockbusters, including Christopher Nolan's newest creation "Tenet."

Jemen: De grootste humanitaire crisis ter wereld die niet vergeten mag worden

18/07/2020

18/07/2020

Onze schrijver Elsa vertelt alles over de oorlog in Jemen die maar niet de nodige aandacht krijgt, en hoe jij kan helpen.

FSR-FMGxMEDIUM: Goodbye council of 2019/2020!

14/07/2020 and

14/07/2020

Together with the members of the FSR-FMG of 2019/2020 Medium is looking back on working together, teambuilding, learning new things and other memories at the end of the member's acedemic year.

Why We Should Cancel ‘Cancel Culture’

13/07/2020

13/07/2020

What does it mean to get cancelled these days? Emma explains the downfall of cancel culture and why it should get cancelled.

FSR-FMGxMEDIUM: File Update

30/06/2020

30/06/2020

This academic year has ended and so has the term of the current student council. In this article, Medium gives you an insight into the FSR-FMG’s achievements of this year.

Netflix’s “Queer Eye” Season 5 Review: Spreading Human Connection in Lonely Times

30/06/2020

30/06/2020

Quynh reviews the latest season of the Netflix Original 'Queer Eye'. This season continues the sociopolitical crusade of the Fab 5 in Philidelphia.

Movie theatres: Safely “escaping” 2020

23/06/2020

23/06/2020

What better way to escape the anxieties this year has brought us than by getting lost in a good movie? This article provides you with a list of Amsterdam's must visit movie theaters, for the ultimate escape from reality.

Usage of Surveillance Drones Over Black Lives Matter Protests in the USA

19/06/2020

19/06/2020

The murder of George Floyd on May 25th, 2020, sparked Black Lives Matter protests all over the U.S. Five years after BLM protests were calling for justice after the murder of Freddie Gray, the U.S. government has resorted to drone surveillance as it did in 2015. However, the questions remain, what are they watching?, why are they watching? and what happens to protesters' data in the footage?

“Er komt een tijd dat stilte verraad is”

18/06/2020

18/06/2020

Na de dood van George Floyd is de wereld gezamenlijk opgestaan om racisme te bestrijden. Elsa schrijft in dit artikel over drie acties die je kan ondernemen om wit privilege en racisme beter te begrijpen en zo je steentje kan bijdragen voor een betere wereld.

The Pros And Cons Of Studying Online

17/06/2020

17/06/2020

Online-learning continues throughout next semester of the UvA. Andrada tells us what this means for the quality of academic education.

How Taylor Swift Defined the 2010s

16/06/2020

16/06/2020

From country girl to pop-star - Danny shows you how Taylor Swift successfully shaped pop culture during the last decade.

bayan escort escort bayan mersin escort bayan escort brazzers tecavüz porno altyazili porno porno hikayeleri turbanlı porno escort bayan bayan escort escort bayan
mersin escort