fbpx
25/04/2019 Communication Science news and articles

The entertainization of school shootings: “Active Shooter” and the marketing of violence

School shootings have become more and more prominent over the years in the United States, but what exactly drives someone to doing such a tragic deed?


There have been a tragic amount of school shootings this year already in America. Most of the times, a student of the school he goes to resorts to gun violence against his fellow students, but what makes an ordinary middle school student walk into his classroom and open fire against his classmates? How can we explain the recurring episodes of violence that plague U.S. public opinion, becoming object of concern for the international community?

On May 25, only one week after the Santa Fe School massacre, a young student injured two after opening fire at Noblesville West Middle School in Noblesville, Indiana. Reality appears staggering: according to CNN, in the first 21 weeks of 2018, there have been 23 incidents similar to the just mentioned one. Everytown for Gun Safety registered over 310 cases of gunfire on school grounds since 2013, with an average of 52 shootings per year: the independent and non-partisan organization, aims at reducing the incidence of school shootings by focusing on the underlying causes of this phenomenon.

A scientific perspective: the exposure to media violence as predictor of teens’ violent behavior
There is no much left to say when looking at these data: violence speaks clearly. Greater interest should therefore be put into the analysis of those that are the triggering factors for the raising gunfire rate at U.S. schools.                    

In the past decades, an incredible amount of research attempted to identify the intrinsic motivations and consequences on youth of the exposure to media violence: scientists wanted to deepen the hypothetical negative influence of violent video games on players’ behavior. The results, however, were mostly conflicting: not even longitudinal studies succeeded in drawing clear and homogeneous conclusions.

Nevertheless, evidence was found proving that violent teenagers are subjected to a worsening of their behavioral traits after being repeatedly exposed to media violence. Should we hence consider violent video games (e.g. Call of Duty and Gears of War) only dangerous for the emotional balance of subjects already presenting other risk factors? Science seems to suggest so, yet it’s hard to tell.

The Anarchist Cookbook: a literary precedent and shooters’ source of inspiration
In 1971, the then 22-year-old William Powell wrote The Anarchist Cookbook: the book is a catalogue of instructions for “the manufacturing of explosives, rudimentary telecommunications phreaking devices, weapons and drugs.” This piece of writing was to be a remonstrance against the U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War. Powell, who eventually regret the publication of his work, is known to have inspired many of the protagonists of the discussed school shootings. His book not only fostered the harmful intentions of the shooters, but it also provided them with factual knowledge concerning the home-made fabrication of their arsenal.

“I have no patience with individuals who claim that everything will be beautiful if guns and other weapons are outlawed. […] There is no justice left in the system. The only real justice is that which the individual creates for himself, and the individual is helpless without a gun.” – William Powell

Conscious of the implications the distribution of this work had for many generations, we are called to contextualize its matter in order to justify the origin of such a controversial book. Product of the counterculture era, The Anarchist Cookbook reflects the dissatisfaction with any established expression of power and authority. After the Second World War, U.S. counterculture activists engaged themselves in the non-violent movement opposing racial segregation and overall racial discrimination. The cultural phenomenon also took position in supporting causes such as environmentalism, minority rights, and birth control. Accordingly, the book needs to be read taking into account the socio-cultural context within which it took shape.

The marketing of violence between profit and ethical implications
Violent video games are also held responsible for the spread of violence within schools. Proposals of video games regulations have been normal agenda since the release of Death Race (1976), the first game to arouse controversies because of its violent content. Titles such as Mortal Kombat (1995) and Night Trap (1993) provoked the foundation of the Entertainment Software Rating Board (Suddath, 2010), an independent panel meant to monitor the presence of violent and sexual content in video games.

Despite the premises featured by the gaming industry in the past decades, not many would have expected such questionable developments: “Active Shooter” is a video game that allows players to simulate school shootings by either taking the role of shooters or the one of SWAT team members. The release date of the computer game was set for June 6: however, the game caused a massive outrage and more than 100,000 people signed a Change.org petition to block its distribution.

Given the role played by entertainment in the spread and maintenance of social norms, behaviors and beliefs, a question which arises is whether profit-driven interests are sufficient to legitimize the selling of violence to the global audiences. Relying on science to raise awareness about the influence of violent media content and personality traits on human behavior, people should lay the foundations of a future in which school shootings are still fortuitos tragedies rather than daily facts.

Countering any form of violence, society needs to prevent further incidents to occur by progressively rebuilding public safety and mutual trust.

Cover: Tim Mudd / Final editing: Kyle Hassing

247 Total Views 1 Views Today

Reacties

reacties

Related Posts

Is Having a Restricted Press Really Such a Bad Thing?

22/04/2019

22/04/2019

Having a government-controlled press, singapore has been ranked 150th out of 180 countries on the World Freedom Press Index. But is this controlled press really a bad thing in a time were fake news thrives?

Backstage bij Dotcomspot: Raf

19/04/2019

19/04/2019

In deze editie van backstage sprak Medium met Raf die stage loopt bij Dotcomsport.

Medium Podcast #5 – It’s getting hot in here: how to survive Climate Change

18/04/2019

18/04/2019

Medium's brand new podcast on climate change and how to survive it, go listen!

Added social value and the active audience

18/04/2019

18/04/2019

The media we know today isn't the way it has always been. In the three 'ages' that media has gone through, an awful lot has changed.

Trials by Media: The Case of Madeleine McCann

17/04/2019

17/04/2019

How the missing case of Madeleine McCann, rocked the world and made us reconsider the role of the media, mediatisation and framing in modern news cycles.

GDPR: (Finally) A Legislation For The Digital World

16/04/2019

16/04/2019

Medium editor Eva Oravcova joined the 'The Two Faces of Facebook' debate on the 11th of April. On the basis of this debate, hosted by ASIF Ventures, Eva dives into the GDPR and explains us everything we need to know.

De snelle dood van Google’s kunstmatige intelligentie raad

14/04/2019

14/04/2019

Naar aanleiding van een enorme groei in kunstmatige intelligentie, heeft Google het ATEAC opgericht. Deze kunstmatige intelligentie raad kreeg echter veel interne kritiek en werd na slechts een week alweer opgedoekt. Medium zocht uit waarom.

Students of Amsterdam: Aakansha

10/04/2019

10/04/2019

Back again with another Students of Amsterdam feature, Medium chats with communication science student, Aakansha, about life and study in Amsterdam.

Media Regulation in the United States

09/04/2019

09/04/2019

Media industries in the United States facing regulations because they are very powerful. Medium dived into this interesting phenomena.

The European Elections: Basic Guide to What, Why and How

08/04/2019

08/04/2019

Having troubles with the when and how about the European elections? No stress, Medium helps you out!

Yellow Vests, The Symbol of a Rising Working Class

05/04/2019

05/04/2019

Headlining the newspapers for the past months, the Yellow Vests have proven not only to be of practical use, but to serve as a symbol of a rising working class as well.

What the Hell is Communication Science?

04/04/2019

04/04/2019

A frustrated meditation on what it means to study communication science at the University of Amsterdam, courtesy of Hahae, a second year student.

Communication Science meets Heritage Studies

03/04/2019

03/04/2019

Can history be studied merely objectively or also subjectively? Communication science and heritages studies students discuss the importance of an interdisciplinary approach.

Sport en social media: Een gouden combinatie?

03/04/2019

03/04/2019

Iedere sportorganisatie gebruikt tegenwoordig fanatiek social media om in contact te blijven met de fans. Daarnaast kan dit ook erg lucratief zijn.

Students of Amsterdam: Terézia

02/04/2019

02/04/2019

Let us introduce Terézia. Originally from Slovakia, Terézia has moved to Amsterdam to study psychology, bringing a piece of home with her in the form of folk dancing.

EnjoyInstagram