fbpx
27/02/2020 The magazine by Communication Science students of the UvA

What some people don’t get about this year’s Oscars controversy… Again

A critical analysis of why The Oscars, as the most prominent awards of the film industry, are not up to date with diversity and its importance.


On January 13th the 92nd Academy Awards announced this year’s nominations. And they were overwhelmingly white and male. This outturn gave me flashbacks to 2016 when the infamous #OscarsSoWhite was trending because all 20 actors nominated were Caucasian. Since then, a lot of non-white actors specifically have been nominated, and some even won in the following years. But now we’re in 2020, and things seem to be back to square one. The only thought that came to me was that meme: “disappointed, but not surprised.’’

First of all, it’s odd how the Oscars let two prominent actors of color John Cho and Issa Rae, announce the nomination. When meanwhile, the actual nominees don’t reflect this at all, but this is definitely not the first time.

The traditional gender gap in the film industry

One of the biggest controversies was that no women were nominated for Best Director, while there were so many ground-breaking female directors in 2019 compared to any other year. Most notable were Lulu Wang (The Farewell), Greta Gerwig (Little Women), Lorene Scafaria (Hustlers), and Olivia Wilde (Booksmart). These movies were all critically acclaimed and generally praised as well, so at least one of these has been snubbed. Award-announcer Issa Rae even gave shade at the end by saying: “Congratulations to those men’’.

Internalized racism left and right

Now let’s get to the 20 actors that were nominated this year for best actors and best-supporting actors. Cynthia Erivo, in the category of Best Lead Actress, was the only person of color that was nominated for an acting role. She played the role of Harriet Tubman in Harriet, who was a historical figure who escaped slavery and became an abolitionist and political activist. This reminded me of a meme I saw on Twitter last year: “Award season be like: ‘And your nominees are… White person, white person, black person playing a slave, white person.’’’. This is a prime example of what kind of stories about minorities, the Oscar voting members do regard as “worthy’’ for nomination.

The astonishing thing was also that many critically acclaimed films in the past year had lead actors of color such as Jennifer Lopez (Hustlers), Awkwafina (The Farewell), Lupita Nyong’o (Us), and Eddie Murphy (Dolemite is my Name). Jennifer Lopez, who played the complex role of Ramona in Hustlers based on real-life, and Awkwafina, who won a Golden Globe for her role in The Farewell, were all highly expected to receive a nomination.

Diversity and quality are NOT mutually exclusive

What I’ve heard a lot of people say when things like this are repeatedly happening in media entertainment, is that it’s not about diversity, but about the “best’’ work and performers. First of all, this is a very dangerous statement to make because it implies that diversity and quality are mutually exclusive, which is definitely not. Second, they can be synonymous, but a lot of industries simply see only quality from one type of demographic.

It’s really easy for a person to just see the quality in artworks where they can see themselves in and can relate to. But relatability for me was always more than just your own skin color or gender; from the white protagonist of Joker to the female protagonists of Little Women, I related to them and their story-lines to certain extents, which made it good quality movies for me.

The white patriarchy’s ego within The Academy

The majority of the 9000-voting members are white and male, and they decide which actors and movies get nominated. This was also noticeable for the Best Picture nominations, in which six out of the nine nominated movies focused on “male tales’’. These stories focus on white (disaffected) masculinities in particular, which is reflected in the voting pool. Of course, I’m not saying these movies aren’t good and worthy. They mostly are quality work, but so are a lot of movies I mentioned previously with the same critical acclaim, featuring predominantly women and people of color.

Diversity inherently doesn’t mean instant quality, but it can definitely lead to more interesting, relatable, and, therefore, higher quality art. Ground-breaking nominees for Best Picture were Little Women, with a predominantly female cast and Parasite, with a South-Korean cast and being the only non-English-speaking film, which is a milestone.

Art is, after all subjective, and who the judges are really matters. If the majority of voters are one type of demographic – in this case, male and white – then works and performances by people of color and women about people of color and women may very well not be understood first of all, and therefore not appreciated. Or they are not even watched, to begin with. Irrespective of quality, if these works created by minorities are overlooked by institutions predominantly comprised of white men, there is a bias at work. So in what world could it ever be acceptable that some works of art are ignored because these creators and stories weren’t regarded as equal to begin with?

 

Cover: Engin Akyurt

Reacties

reacties

Related Posts

A wrap-up on the International Film Festival Rotterdam Awards Ceremony

27/02/2020

27/02/2020

Medium summarizes the awards of the most prominent film festival in the Netherlands, the International Film Festival in Rotterdam. As one of the largest film festivals in the world, 2020 was the IFFR's 49th edition, hosting masterclasses, screenings, panel discussions, and a huge crowd from the most talented in the film industry.

A Requiem to BoJack Horseman

26/02/2020

26/02/2020

Spanning six seasons, Netflix’s first original animated series BoJack Horseman finally came to an end last January. First dismissed as yet another adult animated show much like The Simpsons and Bob’s Burgers, BoJack Horseman grew to be revered as a brilliantly dark, thoughtful show that doesn’t pull any punches when discussing social issues. Karina discusses the show's brilliance.

Medium Podcast #9- IFFR Interview with Artemio Narro and Manolo Caso

25/02/2020 and

25/02/2020

Medium Podcast went on the field to interview Artemio Narro and Manolo Caso after the world premiere of Narro's second feature film and Caso's acting debut in ColOZio.

Fake News: het dodelijkste virus dat er is

24/02/2020

24/02/2020

Volgens de media zou de halve wereld als besmet zijn met het Coronavirus. Echter valt dit reuze mee en probeert de media ons door fake news bang te maken.

Fake News and the Coronavirus: How the Media verbalize Xenophobia in the New Decade

22/02/2020

22/02/2020

As the Coronavirus spreads so do the misinformation and fake news that lead to xenophobia around the globe. Stephanie writes about her own experience as an Asian student abroad.

Becoming Your Own Life Coach – Living an Enriched Life

21/02/2020

21/02/2020

The series of Becoming Your Own Life Coach reaches its second chapter. Andrada reflects on the applied knowledge of the first book of the series and reviews a second one.

The Road to Acceptance of Queer Women in Media Representation

19/02/2020

19/02/2020

Acceptance or fetishization? This article takes a critical look at the way the media portrays lesbians and their relationships.

Medium Podcast #8 – Jade’s Pact

14/02/2020 and

14/02/2020

The month in which Jade stopped using smartphones and developed a texting twitch (Parents beware).

Personal Ads: Who needs Cupid?

14/02/2020

14/02/2020

From personal ads to dating apps, people have advertised themselves to find the best suitor. Medium tells you why cupid is out of business.

Parasite wins Best Picture without an ’English-speaking’ host

13/02/2020

13/02/2020

Parasite makes history at the 92nd Academy Awards by being the first non-English speaking film to win Best Picture, defeating eight other competing English-language movies. Danny tells us why Parasite deserved to win.

A day in the life of the FSR FMG’s official secretary

13/02/2020

13/02/2020

Have you ever wondered what the secretary of the FSR FMG does? Meet Robin while she tells about her job! The job that currency has a vacancy, so check it out!

“Trust the child within you”: Interview with Francis Alÿs

Medium interviewed Francis Alÿs, director of "Sandlines", which premiered in Europe at the International Film Festival in Rotterdam. His work is currently being exhibited at the Eye Film Museum in Amsterdam.

Black tie: A guide on formal attire

12/02/2020

12/02/2020

Your next formal event is coming up and no idea what to wear? Then this article is the perfect guide in what to wear in ‘black tie’ to the next formal event.  

The Lessons of a Mercurius Sales Committee Member

10/02/2020

10/02/2020

Have you ever wondered what the Sales Committee of the study association Mercurius exactly does? Margarete gives you an insight into the useful skills she has developed as part of the committee.

Vienna: City of dreams

10/02/2020

10/02/2020

The Austrian capital is a worldwide famous destination with all sorts of architecture, museums, and landmarks to visit. If you are an art or history lover, a foodie, or you just get a thrill out of traveling to a new place; Vienna is the place for you!

mersin escort mersin escort mersin escort canlı tv konya escort